Brokerage Barrage

Every single thing that ails the business of residential real estate can be traced back to one specific day in August of 2006. On the 29th day of that month Million Dollar Listing premiered on Bravo, and the world of real estate has not been the same since. Prior to this date, superstar brokers worked their specific geographic market niche. Once they had done so for long enough to sufficiently gather enough money to retire they chose not to, instead following the age old real estate retirement procedure which goes something like this: Work until no one wants to work with you and then fade into oblivion. As one local real estate broker once told me, “I guess I retired, but no one told me.” That was a cute way of selling real estate, and it worked rather well, right up until August of 2006.

That show followed some goofy realtors around coastal California, and after some time we realized that agents aren’t just property tour guides, but they’re something more. They’re tour guides, sure, but they’re also remarkably egotistical, superficial, and frantic. Josh Flagg burst onto the scene as some sort of supposed wunderkind, even though his entire business existed only because his grandmother was a well known, equally well heeled, Beverly Hills matron of style and affluence. Even so, the Josh’s and Madison, with his bleary eyes, and Chad, with his Beatles cut, showed the world the upper end world of real estate made for good television.

After a few seasons of showcasing the specific geographic niches that each agent worked, the agents started crossing over. The Beverly Hills guy started to show in Malibu. The Malibu guy took listings in San Diego. The Beverly Hills guys followed their parents to vacation in Aspen and showed a few mountain homes while there. The concept of speciality focused geographic market expertise was officially dead. Any agent worth his or her salt was showing homes in Malibu and Naples and Jackson Hole. Expertise be damned, if there’s money to made the agents would travel and lend a hand by not understanding specific market nuance. The real estate world was changing. Personality mattered more than qualification.

Then came Serhant and his silver hair and excitable take on everything. This is the most INSANE closet he’d ever seen! he’d say many times a show. This is a ONCE IN A LIFETIME OPPORTUNITY, but so is THIS. Ryan propelled this new sort of personality (being excited about everything) and has since parlayed it into a nationwide expansion of his own eponymous brokerage. He’s following Compass, which followed @Properties, which sort of followed, or ran in tandem with Sotheby’s. Meanwhile Engel and Voelkers is knocking on doors and the Agency out of California is doing what they can to find relevance outside of a specific geography. Berkshire Hathaway Home Services grew into the residential brokerage space by buying MidAmerican Energy, which owned HomeServices of America, which in turn owned regional juggernauts like Edina Realty (Minnesota). Berkshire then bought Prudential Realty, which no one has heard of, to launch their own effort to compete with the rush of new business models. Real estate was being transformed, the industry insisted.

The concept of a a roll-up is something we all generally understand. If I own one orthodontic practice, then maybe I should own 14. If I own 14, maybe some smart guys in a big tower will decide that if they buy my 14 and combine it with eight other people who own 14, then maybe something bigger is possible. This PE boom has fueled real estate markets worldwide, and we’d have to be blind and also dumb to not see this phenomenon feather our own nest at Lake Geneva. But the roll up world isn’t unique to orthodontists and electricians, it’s heavy and rampant in the world of real estate. As the behemoth brokerages grew, so did their appetite for growth. At Properties grew by acquihire, and then Compass ate them as part of their own growth strategy. Sotheby’s expanded in a similar fashion, but they once hosted me at their headquarters in New Jersey and that’s where I found out the inside of their office looked like a DMV in rural Wisconsin and I decided that whatever was next was not really for me. I did get a nice steak dinner out of it and a couple of Sotheby’s pens. Bic, as I recall.

The billboards around Chicago are telling you that Serhant has arrived. He even spent a night (one, maybe two, maybe none?) and told his new agents that INSANE things are happening. CHICAGO IS INSANE! He had to have said this. And the agents who had previously left Coldwell for At Properties who then became Compass agents, but only sort of, are now Serhant agents. This will be their chance to shine, with all of the borrowed personality of their narcissist in chief. The cycle appears complete, until The Agency rolls in and promises a neater back office CRM (proprietary!) and/or Michael Jordan decides its time for Air Realty, at which point the new office will be painted mostly red and black, unless it’s in the American South, where the colors will be tar heel blue.

This is nothing but a reminder that what is next in real estate is the same as it’s always been. There is nothing new under the sun, there are only regurgitated ideas with fresh wrapping. Serhant isn’t what’s next anymore than At Properties was what’s next. Robert Reffkin is at the helm of Compass, and his career proves that the future of real estate is not about real estate, but about business. A consultant from McKinsey who then went to Goldman is now running what I presume is the largest real estate company in the world. Why would that be? Why not a realtor who grew beyond his regional boundaries, as Serhant is doing now? Well, it’s because the business of real estate is about nothing more than adding agents. The back office interface and office decor and billboards are all engineered to impress the agent, not the consumer. Because in the growth of a brokerage the consumer is actually the agent. It goes like this: Find agent. Convince agent their business will grow if they have a fancier sign and a CEO on tv. Get agent to switch from their current brokerage to your new brokerage. Claim their volume and tell the world that you are indeed what’s next. This is the business, and I’m sad to see that the American consumer doesn’t fully understand just how this all works. Your agent isn’t Reffkin or Serhant or Umansky, it’s just a guy named Bill who used to work in the finance department at a Honda dealership. If you trust that Bill knows your target market extremely well and he is able to give you advice that seeks to further your goals and not his own, work with Bill. Who does he work for? Who cares?

At the lake, I’m not what’s next. I’m likely what has been. But I also dominate a very specific market niche, and I welcome the supposed competition that can only be offered by New York agents with a billboard budget.

About the Author

I'm David Curry. I write this blog to educate and entertain those who subscribe to the theory that Lake Geneva, Wisconsin is indeed the center of the real estate universe. When I started selling real estate 30 years ago I did so of a desire to one day dominate the activity in the Lake Geneva vacation home market. With over $1,000,000,000 in career sales, that goal is within reach. If I can help you with your Lake Geneva real estate needs, please consider me at your service. Thanks for reading.

Leave a Comment